The Sixth Molecule:
Why E-Ethanol Will Not Come From a Catalyst
Ethanol is absent from every list of electrofuels, and the absence is not an oversight. Making it from CO₂ and hydrogen means forming a carbon–carbon bond, which is precisely the reaction catalysts perform worst — the chemistry would rather give you methanol, and does. The electrochemical route has produced a striking laboratory result on an electrode of one square centimetre. A second route exists, almost nobody writes about it, and it replaces the catalyst with bacteria. This article sets out what is proven, what has gone quiet, and the legal trap that has already brought one Belgian plant to the brink.
The Molecule That Is Missing From Every List — and Why That Is Not an Oversight
Open any account of electrofuels and you will find the same five products: ammonia, methanol, methane, synthetic kerosene and diesel, and synthetic petrol. Ethanol is not among them. This is strange on its face. Ethanol is a liquid. The world already moves it, stores it and burns it by the hundred million tonnes. There is a certified route from alcohol to aviation fuel.[6] So why is it absent?
The answer is a single chemical bond. Making methanol from CO₂ and hydrogen means hydrogenating a carbon–oxygen double bond — in the words of a 2026 review in Chemical Science, “a thermodynamically favourable process with relatively modest kinetic barriers”. Making ethanol means something else entirely: joining two carbon atoms to one another. The same review calls this “C1-to-C2 transition” the central challenge in CO₂ valorization, and explains why it is so stubborn: the coupling “must outcompete dominant C1 termination routes” — that is, it must beat methanol and methane, which form more readily.[1]
Producing ethanol from CO₂, the review states, requires “intentionally deviating from the thermodynamically spontaneous and kinetically favored C1 pathway”.[1] Every molecule on the standard e-fuel list works with the chemistry. Ethanol asks the chemistry to do the thing it least wants to do.
What the Laboratory Has Actually Achieved — and at What Size
The electrochemical route — electricity, water and CO₂ into a cell, ethanol out — has produced genuinely impressive results. In July 2025 a team published 87.21% faradaic efficiency to ethanol at an industrially relevant current density, holding above 70% for three hundred hours. Before that work, the authors note, no catalyst had been reported that reached 70% for even one hundred and fifty hours at such a current density; designing one, they write, remains “a tremendous challenge”.[2]
That result was obtained on an electrode measuring one square centimetre.[2] It is worth sitting with that number before reading any projection built on it. A techno-economic assessment published in September 2026 did the arithmetic of scaling it: a plant making ten thousand tonnes a year would need roughly 1,508 square metres of active electrode area — fifteen million times the demonstrated area — and the authors are blunt that “the combined performance target has not been demonstrated” and that “a 300 h test does not establish a stack lifetime”.[3]
Their cost figures settle the matter for now. Minimum selling price: €2.51 per kilogram with electricity at zero, €3.24 at two cents a kilowatt-hour, and €6.12 at ten cents.[3] Set that beside the thing it would have to displace. In the week of 20 October 2026 the United States Department of Agriculture reported plant-gate ethanol between $1.83 and $2.17 a gallon depending on the state, which works out at roughly €0.55 to €0.65 per kilogram.[10] Electrochemical ethanol would therefore cost somewhere between four and eleven times the conventional product, depending entirely on the price of electricity. These are American plant-gate prices, and we found no official European index to set against them.
The electrochemical route is not an industry waiting for scale. It is a square centimetre of electrode, and an honest paper saying so.
The Route Nobody Writes About — It Is Biological
Set the catalyst aside and the problem looks different. Carbon–carbon coupling is not hard for everything — it is hard for metals. Acetogenic bacteria have been joining carbon atoms as part of their ordinary metabolism for a very long time, and gas fermentation puts them to work: feed them carbon monoxide, or carbon dioxide with hydrogen, and they return ethanol. No precious metal, no high pressure, no electrode. One company, LanzaTech, has six commercial gas fermentation plants running today, in China, India and Europe.[4]
But almost all of those plants eat industrial waste gas, not CO₂ and hydrogen — steel mill off-gas, refinery gas — and that distinction is the whole question. Exactly one announced project would close it: a plant at Lara, in the Indian state of Chhattisgarh, built with NTPC, taking CO₂ captured from flue gas together with green hydrogen from a 7.5 MW electrolyser.[5] It was announced in mid-2024 and expected to begin operations within two years. That window has now closed.
No announcement of construction starting. No commissioning. No delay, and no cancellation either. Neither NTPC, nor LanzaTech, nor the engineering contractor has said anything publicly about this plant since August 2024. LanzaTech’s first- and second-quarter results for 2026 do not mention it. NTPC’s own sustainability presentation, dated 31 October 2025, lists its carbon-capture pilots — CO₂-to-methanol at Vindhyachal as commissioned, CO₂-to-aviation-fuel at Pudimadaka as planned — and the Lara ethanol plant is not among them.[5]
Silence is not cancellation, and we do not report it as one. But on a page that counts plants rather than announcements, a project whose own deadline has passed without a word from any of the three parties building it belongs in the column marked unproven.
It is also, as far as we can establish, the only one of its kind. The companies that genuinely ferment CO₂ with hydrogen today make acetate, acetic acid or protein rather than ethanol — and two of the three we identified have ceased trading. The large gas fermentation plants that do make ethanol, at Ghent and in Japan, all run on carbon-monoxide-rich industrial gas. We should be straight about the shape of that finding: it is the result of targeted searching, not of an exhaustive census
Why It Would Matter — and the Trap Underneath
If low-carbon ethanol could be made at a reasonable price, there is a regulated market waiting for it. The alcohol-to-jet pathway is certified under Annex A5 of ASTM D7566, approved for ethanol in April 2018 and permitted in blends of up to 50%.[6] And it is no longer theoretical: in November 2025 LanzaJet announced jet fuel to ASTM specification and full plant operation at Freedom Pines Fuels in Georgia — twenty-two months after the plant opened, which is its own lesson about how long these things take.[7] Anyone who could make ethanol from CO₂ and electricity would reach synthetic aviation fuel without Fischer-Tropsch.
Aviation is where the prize would be, and the rules there are sharper than most summaries admit. ReFuelEU Aviation requires 2% sustainable aviation fuel from 2025, 6% from 2030, 20% from 2035 and 70% by 2050 — and inside those shares sits a separate sub-quota reserved for synthetic fuels: 1.2% on average across 2030 and 2031, 2% across 2032 to 2034, then at least 5% from 2035, 10% from 2040 and 35% by 2050.[9] Ethanol from food and feed crops is excluded from the calculation of the minimum shares altogether, and any aviation biofuel that is neither advanced nor made from an Annex IX Part B feedstock is capped at 3%.[9] Corn ethanol, in other words, is not a route into this market at all. Reading the definitions together, alcohol-to-jet made from bio-ethanol counts as an aviation biofuel and would not fill the synthetic sub-quota, whereas ethanol made from CO₂ and renewable hydrogen would fall on the synthetic side of the line — which is precisely where the binding shortage is. We present that as a reading of the text rather than as a settled point: the regulation names neither ethanol nor the alcohol-to-jet route anywhere.
There is a trap underneath all of this, and it is worth naming plainly, because it is where most ethanol in the world would fall. Under FuelEU Maritime, fuels produced from food and feed crops carry the emission factor of the least favourable fossil pathway.[8] Corn ethanol and cane ethanol therefore deliver no compliance benefit at all, however green the marketing. The feedstock is not a detail of the story. It is the story.
The Warning From Ghent — a Plant Caught Between Two Definitions
Belgium has a cautionary tale on this exact point, and it has had remarkably little coverage. ArcelorMittal’s Steelanol plant at Ghent ferments blast-furnace gas into ethanol: sixty thousand tonnes a year, €215 million of investment, thirty-five jobs. In 2025 the company said it was giving itself about a year to decide whether to shut it down. The reason given was not technical. The ethanol was recognised neither as an advanced biofuel nor as a recycled carbon fuel, so the emissions it avoids could not be counted.[11]
A molecule can work, find a buyer, and still fail — because no legal category fits it. Anyone betting on ethanol from CO₂ should establish which category the product will fall into before establishing that the chemistry works. On current European definitions the distinction turns on where the energy comes from, not on where the carbon comes from: a fuel whose energy is renewable electricity is a renewable fuel of non-biological origin even when its carbon came from a fossil flue gas, whereas a fuel whose energy is the waste gas itself is a recycled carbon fuel, counted differently.
What to Watch
Three things, and none of them is a catalyst paper. First, whether anyone connected with the Indian plant breaks silence, in either direction. Second, whether LanzaJet’s Georgia plant runs at a utilisation anyone is willing to publish — it has never disclosed a production volume. Third, whether European law finds a category for ethanol made from industrial carbon, because Ghent shows what happens when it does not.
Our own position, stated plainly so it can be argued with: ethanol deserves a place in the e-fuel conversation, but not the place its advocates claim. The electrochemical route is a laboratory result of real quality and no industrial relevance yet. The biological route is a proven industrial process that has not yet been shown to work on this particular feedstock, and the one project meant to show it has said nothing for over two years. And today, the most important thing ethanol contributes to synthetic fuels is not the alcohol at all — it is the carbon dioxide coming off the fermenters, which is among the cheapest concentrated CO₂ available anywhere, and which is already feeding e-kerosene plants. For now, ethanol’s contribution to e-fuels is its exhaust.
- Wenhao Zheng, Yang Liu, Xin Zhang et al., “Atomic-level engineering of single-atom catalysts for selective C–C coupling in CO₂ hydrogenation to ethanol”, Chemical Science, vol. 17, no. 17, 2026, pp. 8432–8452 (the carbon–carbon coupling problem, and why methanol forms instead). https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC13054590/
- Hao Liu et al., “Highly efficient and stable ethanol electrosynthesis from carbon dioxide at −250 mA cm⁻²”, Nature Communications, vol. 16, article 6186, 4 July 2025 (87.21% faradaic efficiency; above 70% sustained for 300 hours; electrode area 1 cm²). https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12297407
- Ankit Gupta and Michael Harasek, “Techno-Economic Feasibility, Uncertainty, and Scale-Up Requirements for Electrochemical CO₂-to-Ethanol Production”, Sustainable Chemistry, vol. 7, no. 4, article 55, 23 September 2026 (minimum selling price of €2.514, €3.235 and €6.120 per kilogram at electricity prices of €0, €0.02 and €0.10 per kilowatt-hour; 1,508 m² of active area for 10,000 tonnes a year; the combined performance target is not demonstrated). https://www.mdpi.com/2673-4079/7/4/55
- LanzaTech Global, Investor Overview, May 2026, filed with the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (six commercial gas fermentation plants operating; the NTPC project in India listed as “CO₂ and Green H₂” in the project pipeline, not in operation). https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1843724/000162828026029858/ltoverviewmay2026.htm
- LanzaTech Global, “LanzaTech awarded contract by Jakson Green to supply NTPC its 4G ethanol technology for next-gen carbon recycling facility”, 7 August 2024 (an annual CO₂ abatement capacity of 7,300 tonnes; operations expected to begin within two years; no ethanol volume given). Trade coverage of the same award gives 25 tonnes of ethanol a day in one account and 10 in another; the figures have never been reconciled, and no party has published one since. The absence of the project from NTPC’s own sustainability presentation of 31 October 2025 is noted in the text. https://markets.financialcontent.com/custercountychief/article/gnwcq-2024-8-7-lanzatech-awarded-contract-by-jakson-green-to-supply-ntpc-its-4g-ethanol-technology-for-next-gen-carbon-recycling-facility
- Commercial Aviation Alternative Fuels Initiative, “Fuel Qualifications”, consulted 27 October 2026 (the alcohol-to-jet route, Annex A5 of ASTM D7566, approved for ethanol in April 2018, in blends of up to 50%). The standard itself is not freely available. https://www.caafi.org/fuel-qualifications
- LanzaJet, “LanzaJet makes history as the world’s first to produce jet fuel from ethanol at commercial-scale plant”, 13 November 2025 (jet fuel to ASTM specification and full plant operation at Freedom Pines Fuels, Soperton, Georgia, twenty-two months after the plant opened). https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/lanzajet-makes-history-as-the-worlds-first-to-produce-jet-fuel-from-ethanol-at-commercial-scale-plant-delivering-the-next-generation-fuel-solution-for-aviation-302614094.html
- Regulation (EU) 2023/1805 on the use of renewable and low-carbon fuels in maritime transport (FuelEU Maritime), Article 10(1)(a) and recitals 25 and 28 (fuels produced from food and feed crops carry the emission factor of the least favourable fossil pathway). https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=CELEX%3A32023R1805
- Regulation (EU) 2023/2405 on ensuring a level playing field for sustainable air transport (ReFuelEU Aviation): Article 3(7), (8) and (12) for the definitions; Article 4(4) for the 3% cap on aviation biofuels that are neither advanced nor made from an Annex IX Part B feedstock; Article 4(5) excluding food and feed crops from the calculation of the minimum shares; Annex I for the shares of sustainable aviation fuel and the sub-quota of synthetic fuels. https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/PDF/?uri=OJ:L_202302405
- United States Department of Agriculture, Agricultural Marketing Service, National Weekly Ethanol Report, 23 October 2026 (plant-gate prices, free on board: Iowa $1.83 to $1.85 a gallon, Nebraska $1.91, Illinois $2.09 to $2.10, Indiana $2.14 to $2.17). The report publishes no national average, and the address serves the current week, so these are the figures for the week of 20 October 2026. No official European ethanol price index was found. https://www.ams.usda.gov/mnreports/ams_3616.pdf
- Belga News Agency, “Europe puts flagship green project in jeopardy: ArcelorMittal considers shutting down the Steelanol plant in Ghent”, and Flows, “ArcelorMittal: Steelanol project at risk from European regulation”, June 2025 (the Ghent plant, 60,000 tonnes of ethanol a year, €215 million; the ethanol recognised neither as an advanced biofuel nor as a recycled carbon fuel). The Belga page carries no visible date. https://en.flows.be/ports/2025/06/arcelormittal-steelanol-project-at-risk-from-european-regulation/
Every factual claim above is referenced to its publication and date. Where no source could be found, that is stated rather than filled in. Part of this content was produced with the assistance of an artificial intelligence system, in accordance with Regulation (EU) 2024/1689, Article 50. Published by BESS Energie SRL, Avenue Reine Astrid 224 boîte 1, 4802 Heusy (Verviers), Belgium — BCE / VAT BE 0698.949.732 — info@bess.be. This site is independent and is not affiliated with any of the organisations mentioned.




